Cynthia & Caitlin

Based on live asking prices we track on eBay, fair value for a Cynthia & Caitlin PSA 10 sits around $560 right now, with current asks ranging from about $420 to $606 across 7 live listings. Keep in mind asking prices usually run a little above what cards actually sell for, so treat this as a well-informed guide, not an appraisal.

Early but real: since we started tracking it on October 1, fair value has moved from $568 to $560 — down about 1%. That's a short window, so treat it as directional rather than a trend. Fair value here is a trimmed median of live asks, recomputed a few times a day — the chart on this page has the whole line.

As of our last sweep, 7 live eBay listings passed our identity checks for this exact slab, asking from $420 delivered (item + shipping). That's our radar's verified view, not all of eBay — listings without clear photos or a provable match don't count, and sellers list and delist all day. Every one we see is in the Available Now rail on this page.

It's the Cynthia & Caitlin from Cosmic Eclipse, card number 228/236, professionally graded 10 by PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator). The grade and cert number on the slab make this exact card identifiable and priceable — that's why our radar tracks graded copies only.

Grade is most of the story: a single grade step can move the price dramatically, and even within one grade, listings differ on seller reputation, photo quality, and shipping. That spread is exactly what our radar watches — when someone lists a legitimate copy well below the going rate, it shows up on our deal board. Card grading, explained simply →

Right now our Deal Radar sees 7 live listings for this card priced at least 10% below the fair value we compute — they're badged in the Available Now rail on this page. Every purchase happens on eBay, with eBay buyer protection.